May 2–16, 2009
Enrico Asthon: Christopher Bolduc*, Josué Cerón, Alex Lawrence
Lucia: Jessica Rose Cambio, Colleen Daly*, Angela Meade
Edgardo: Michael Fabiano*, Raffaele Sepe
Arturo Bucklaw: Taylor Stayton
Raimondo Bidebent: Nicholas Masters, Ben Wager*
Alisa: Nina Yoshida Nelsen
Normanno: Noah Van Niel